D-SIPL Moderator Posts: 1345 From: Maesteg, Wales Registered: 07-21-2001 |
What's everyones opinion on "Christian Goths"? Do you beleive you can be a christian and a Goth? I don't know enough about it myself, but i always associated goths, with people who are into 'all things dark'. Perhaps i'm wrong? So what do you lot think?? --D-SIPL |
InsanePoet Member Posts: 638 From: Vermont, USA Registered: 03-12-2003 |
HAHA, I thought of this once. It's "Death, Doom, and Destruction... and Jesus saves you from it" ------------------ |
Rat? Junior Member Posts: 8 From: Hull, Yorkshire, United Kingdom. Registered: 07-24-2001 |
I know lots of goths, non of them seem to be christian though, and a lot of them are into 'dark things'. But you can get chrstian goths. I have some vague memory of hearing orrigenally goths were all christian or something like that. ------------------ |
Angel Member Posts: 699 From: The Blissful State Of Me? Registered: 05-21-2001 |
Hello I came back! HA-HA-HA K so this post interested me and thats why I'm back posting. Anyways I just happen to be a Christian/Goth/Punk/Cowboy/Freak/Scenstar/Hardcore/ This is about Goth thow so I will stick to that subject. Why would I clame to be such a thing and what does God have anything to do with darkness? Well for one Jesus was the first born of the dead. Thats right He was the first to die and go to God free of sin. Then as for darkness it says in the Bible that God dwells in thick darkness. We are also to be dead to this world. Christian goths are real and they are God's Children. Christian Goths also do not focus fully on death and distruction. Thow Christ came to bring the sward it is not for us to take up. Vengeance is mine says the Lord. We do however focuse on the fact that God did send His son to die for us. That is a death. Blood is a big thing too. For without the Blood of Christ we would all be dammed to everlasting flame. SO befor you start narking on people you dont even know much less try to understand take a good lesson from Jesus "Juge not lest ye shell be Juged". Now aside from Christian Goths I would like to point out something about non-Christian Goths. I have met many of them and they are not the evil people many wish to clame them to be. Many of them injoy just sitting in a corner with a book and a capacheno. Many of them are willing to be much more friendly then many Christians I have known. The big thing is that they are not Saved. People calling them evil and treating them bad only encorages them that their way of life is best. We need to show the Love of Christ and not juge or pull down or try to scair people to Christ. Then again take it like my dad used to tell me and his grandparents befor him "If you cant say something nice dont say nothing at all"! Thats my view on Goths. They are just missunderstud and people fear what they do not understand. Azariah "Angel" *I got the Joy- Joy- Joy- Joy- down in my heart!* Sorry great concert last night and I ended up having the Holy Ghost tickle me for about an hours worth of laghter. ------------------ |
Angel Member Posts: 699 From: The Blissful State Of Me? Registered: 05-21-2001 |
Ezekiel 39, 17 "As for you, son of man, thus says the Lord GOD: Speak to the birds of every sort and to all beasts of the field, 'Assemble and come, gather from all sides to the sacrificial feast which I am preparing for you, a great sacrificial feast upon the mountains of Israel, and you shall eat flesh and drink blood. 18 You shall eat the flesh of the mighty, and drink the blood of the princes of the earth--of rams, of lambs, and of goats, of bulls, all of them fatlings of Bashan. 19 And you shall eat fat till you are filled, and drink blood till you are drunk, at the sacrificial feast which I am preparing for you. 20 And you shall be filled at my table with horses and riders, with mighty men and all kinds of warriors,' says the Lord GOD. That is part of one of the Christian Goth bands I liston to. They use peaces of the Bible for their songs ^_^ and give you the scriptures. The Bible is full of really neat things. Just reading that puts the fear of the Lord in me. I wouldnt want to be on the receving end of all the things God could or has done or will do. Well I dont have to worry about that im Saved I just wanted to post this cuz people make God out to be a sissy and He is deffenitly all powerfull! Azariah "Angel" PS: I do not drink blood just so you know. The taist is not to my likeing. Flesh on the other hand (Deppending on where it is from) can be very good. |
Mack Administrator Posts: 2779 From: Registered: 01-20-2001 |
I am a Christian Goth, I tried to hide it from everyone because I was shunned and rejected for it in churches, school, whatever. Now that I'm getting deeper into God and cleaning my life, He's bringing me back to that and I haven't been happier and I don't care what people think because I listen to God and not people. I am more deeply gothic minded than dressed, you don't need to dress like a goth to be a goth, because you can dress like a goth and not be a goth, or you can think like a goth and not be dressed like one.
This article is an exerpt from "What is Christian Goth" by Joseph J. kopnick SOURCE 1 - Thomas Woodroofe - The Eternal Chapter Goth has about as many definitions as it has adherents. You will find that everyone has their own subjective opinion as to what Goth is all about. For me Goth is something that has always been with me. I equate it with having a darker, and perhaps more serious view of life and the world. It is far more than just a musical subculture. It is a way of life. Once I received Christ, I never lost my culture. There were certain things that had to go, certain things that didn't glorify God. But I still loved Siouxsie and Bauhaus along with my new found faith in the Lord Jesus. I found that, contrary to popular 'Christian' opinion, I could still wear lace and velvet (and, God forbid- eyeliner?) and worship Christ. At first I thought I was the only one- Surely there weren't other Christians that shared my passion for Goth and served Jesus? God soon brought me into contact with others just like me. When I first found Saviour Machine's debut album, I was amazed and excited. Here were a group of Christians that perceived things in a similar fashion to me, yet they professed the Christian faith. There is a need for Christians to be a witness in every single culture on the face of this planet. God can use all of us right where we are. There is a tendency amongst Christians to shun that which is different from the norm. Some Christians tend to view white, mainstream, western culture as Christian. This leads to a complete disregard of the valid expressions of other subcultures and cultures. This is entirely wrong. The Bible is clearthat all cultures will have their place in the kingdom of heaven. My sincere hope is that all Christians will become as accepting of others as our Lord Jesus was. SOURCE 2 - Joseph J. Kopnick - Killingtheoldman As you have already read, there are a myriad of views as to what Gothic is and is not. The truth is, there is no really accurate or definitive answer as to exactly what Goth is. The same can be said about the Christian Gothic aesthetic. But suffice to say that Christians that are gothic have an understanding and appreciation for things artistically dark, stunning and dramatic. One MUST NOT equate dark artistic aesthetic with evil. When the bible talks about darkness, it is NOT the same as dark artistic aesthetic. Justifying the Conundrum Let me first begin by saying that I cannot speak for the masses. I can only tell you how I believe Gothic and Christianity relate to and complement one another in my own life. Many may or may not agree with what I believe. Please do not approach this as a be all end all definition of Christian Gothica. Goths on the whole are fiercely independent and eclectic, so my personal opinion will not be shared by all (or even the majority of) other Goths. Gothic in its general essence is expression of a dark aesthetic through various medium including Art, Music, Literature, Architecture, Lifestyle, Attitude and Outlook. I use the word dark here for lack of a better term, perhaps it may should be modified with words like "dramatic" or "high contrast", but for simplicity's sake, we'll use the term dark. I personally feel that of all the sub-cultures that exists, Gothic has some of the most startling ties with Christianity. Below are a few examples. Drink from me and forever live And Jesus wept Melancholy but happy In remembrance of me Deconstruction for Reconstruction ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ This is a personal question to me, so I will address what being "gothic" means to me and why I have chosen to embrace this lifestyle. Let me start by explaining how and why I became a "goth." I jokingly say that my dear friend Chase sired me to the "dark side," because he was the first one to introduce me to this culture. I became "gothic" during a time of extreme sadness in my life. I was surrounded by others who were telling me to just be happy and I could not. I found solace in the dark sounds of Love and Rockets and Bauhaus. In the Cure, I found honesty of emotion, something I desperately needed. When I became "saved" I noticed that while I had the "light of the world" in my life, I was still an outsider. I could not adapt to the cookie-cutter Christian model. Eventually, I discovered Sanctuary and truly found it the right place for my soul. Now I am a Shadow Dweller, lurking with a candle, holding it out to others, sharing the light and the love of God to those who are also living in the shadows. It is hard to understand the real meaning of who/what a goth is if you are not a part of this scene. To me gothic is more than a fashion choice or a music preference. It is an attitude of how one views the world we live in. Some choose to look at life from a very shallow point of view, i.e., "life is one big party and fun is the big goal in life." Others see it from a "yuppie" perspective, looking for their identity in their work, money, possessions, etc. life from a "gothic" point of view is one that is bleak and somber, thus the dark appearance and style of dress. The world is dark to me, because it's so far from God's holy plan and design, that it saddens me greatly. I express my somberness to the world by my style of dress and demeanor. I relate to the prophet Jeremiah regarded by most as the Weeping Prophet. Being gothic to me is also being real real with myself, real with others, and real with God. I do not hide behind a mask to hide who I am and how I truly feel. When I am happy I express it fully, and when I am sad I express that as well. Most goths express their bleak sadness openly and I see that as an honesty of humanity. I admire the culture for it's open and honest expression of self, no matter how perverse or strange, because this is how God sees us. We cannot hide our sins from Him and it is foolish to think we can. In "normal society," people seem so concerned with appearances, they hide their true selves in order to gain the favor of others. This mask-wearing is accepted, yet stark honesty is often shunned, even by those in the church. This is truly sad. You see, being gothic is more than a fashion statement or a certain style of music. It is a reflection of how one chooses to see the world. This world is lost, hell- bound, and full of people in complete denial, seeking to fill that God-shaped void within them with everything except the Cross. It is a world lacking in honesty of self or honesty toward others. If I were to be anything but "gothic" in my views, I would be among the mask-wearing hypocrites. So I wear black and tell others who will listen that the world is empty and bleak. Yet it does not have to be. Though we live in the darkness, we are not of it. Thanks be to God for that.
This article is an exerpt from "What is Christian Goth" by Joseph J. kopnick SOURCE 1 - Thomas Woodroofe - The Eternal Chapter Goth has about as many definitions as it has adherents. You will find that everyone has their own subjective opinion as to what Goth is all about. For me Goth is something that has always been with me. I equate it with having a darker, and perhaps more serious view of life and the world. It is far more than just a musical subculture. It is a way of life. Once I received Christ, I never lost my culture. There were certain things that had to go, certain things that didn't glorify God. But I still loved Siouxsie and Bauhaus along with my new found faith in the Lord Jesus. I found that, contrary to popular 'Christian' opinion, I could still wear lace and velvet (and, God forbid- eyeliner?) and worship Christ. At first I thought I was the only one- Surely there weren't other Christians that shared my passion for Goth and served Jesus? God soon brought me into contact with others just like me. When I first found Saviour Machine's debut album, I was amazed and excited. Here were a group of Christians that perceived things in a similar fashion to me, yet they professed the Christian faith. There is a need for Christians to be a witness in every single culture on the face of this planet. God can use all of us right where we are. There is a tendency amongst Christians to shun that which is different from the norm. Some Christians tend to view white, mainstream, western culture as Christian. This leads to a complete disregard of the valid expressions of other subcultures and cultures. This is entirely wrong. The Bible is clearthat all cultures will have their place in the kingdom of heaven. My sincere hope is that all Christians will become as accepting of others as our Lord Jesus was. SOURCE 2 - Joseph J. Kopnick - Killingtheoldman As you have already read, there are a myriad of views as to what Gothic is and is not. The truth is, there is no really accurate or definitive answer as to exactly what Goth is. The same can be said about the Christian Gothic aesthetic. But suffice to say that Christians that are gothic have an understanding and appreciation for things artistically dark, stunning and dramatic. One MUST NOT equate dark artistic aesthetic with evil. When the bible talks about darkness, it is NOT the same as dark artistic aesthetic. Justifying the Conundrum Let me first begin by saying that I cannot speak for the masses. I can only tell you how I believe Gothic and Christianity relate to and complement one another in my own life. Many may or may not agree with what I believe. Please do not approach this as a be all end all definition of Christian Gothica. Goths on the whole are fiercely independent and eclectic, so my personal opinion will not be shared by all (or even the majority of) other Goths. Gothic in its general essence is expression of a dark aesthetic through various medium including Art, Music, Literature, Architecture, Lifestyle, Attitude and Outlook. I use the word dark here for lack of a better term, perhaps it may should be modified with words like "dramatic" or "high contrast", but for simplicity's sake, we'll use the term dark. I personally feel that of all the sub-cultures that exists, Gothic has some of the most startling ties with Christianity. Below are a few examples. Drink from me and forever live And Jesus wept Melancholy but happy In remembrance of me Deconstruction for Reconstruction ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ This is a personal question to me, so I will address what being "gothic" means to me and why I have chosen to embrace this lifestyle. Let me start by explaining how and why I became a "goth." I jokingly say that my dear friend Chase sired me to the "dark side," because he was the first one to introduce me to this culture. I became "gothic" during a time of extreme sadness in my life. I was surrounded by others who were telling me to just be happy and I could not. I found solace in the dark sounds of Love and Rockets and Bauhaus. In the Cure, I found honesty of emotion, something I desperately needed. When I became "saved" I noticed that while I had the "light of the world" in my life, I was still an outsider. I could not adapt to the cookie-cutter Christian model. Eventually, I discovered Sanctuary and truly found it the right place for my soul. Now I am a Shadow Dweller, lurking with a candle, holding it out to others, sharing the light and the love of God to those who are also living in the shadows. It is hard to understand the real meaning of who/what a goth is if you are not a part of this scene. To me gothic is more than a fashion choice or a music preference. It is an attitude of how one views the world we live in. Some choose to look at life from a very shallow point of view, i.e., "life is one big party and fun is the big goal in life." Others see it from a "yuppie" perspective, looking for their identity in their work, money, possessions, etc. life from a "gothic" point of view is one that is bleak and somber, thus the dark appearance and style of dress. The world is dark to me, because it's so far from God's holy plan and design, that it saddens me greatly. I express my somberness to the world by my style of dress and demeanor. I relate to the prophet Jeremiah regarded by most as the Weeping Prophet. Being gothic to me is also being real real with myself, real with others, and real with God. I do not hide behind a mask to hide who I am and how I truly feel. When I am happy I express it fully, and when I am sad I express that as well. Most goths express their bleak sadness openly and I see that as an honesty of humanity. I admire the culture for it's open and honest expression of self, no matter how perverse or strange, because this is how God sees us. We cannot hide our sins from Him and it is foolish to think we can. In "normal society," people seem so concerned with appearances, they hide their true selves in order to gain the favor of others. This mask-wearing is accepted, yet stark honesty is often shunned, even by those in the church. This is truly sad. You see, being gothic is more than a fashion statement or a certain style of music. It is a reflection of how one chooses to see the world. This world is lost, hell- bound, and full of people in complete denial, seeking to fill that God-shaped void within them with everything except the Cross. It is a world lacking in honesty of self or honesty toward others. If I were to be anything but "gothic" in my views, I would be among the mask-wearing hypocrites. So I wear black and tell others who will listen that the world is empty and bleak. Yet it does not have to be. Though we live in the darkness, we are not of it. Thanks be to God for that. |
Rat? Junior Member Posts: 8 From: Hull, Yorkshire, United Kingdom. Registered: 07-24-2001 |
ooo.. very well put. (not that i'd know) ------------------ |
Klumsy Administrator Posts: 1061 From: Port Angeles, WA, USA Registered: 10-25-2001 |
about christian goths.. I am not coming against christian goths, but coming from a background of knowing and being involved with many When you are involved in anything, espcially something you clearly indentify yourself with, and your thinking patterns.. our answers can be on different levels too... for example in the next week i'm going to cut my hair.. i've had long hair since i was about 15, various people have commented on it in different ways , my mother and wife and friends think it looks very good on me, my grandmother and others think its wrong for a man to have such long hair, some guys checked me out from the back at a fair once thinking i was a hot girl until i turned around with a beard, etc... different peoples judgements on it could be because of their own hangups or not...i can choose to get offended or not. i can ask myself "why do i have long hair?" but lately i feel that God is leading me to cut it, why is it because long hair is intrisically wrong and any guy with hair previsouly i could have asked myself honestly why i still have long hair and don't want to cut it short. and even in full honestly the real reason (and thus the reason why i need tocut it).. however healing is not always complete and takes time, and cutting my hair brings memory of when i had short hair anyway what as that got to do with Goth.. just to encourage anybody, in the subculture they are in, and strongly identify with,
many things can be idols to us, we put them above God in our lives and indentify with them or hold on to them to tight. anyhow about IDOLS, many people have idols, for some T.V or sport can be an idol, for others music, for some nicey nicey christians as some of those articles pointed out, we can align think our culture is christianity, they said the "white nicey nicey" christian viewpoint.. its a sad fact that even missionairies have been preaching western culture rather than christianity so many times..
quote: The above statement is true, however if it comes from rebellion against the norm (even rebellion against things that "should" be There are dangers in the goth mindsets that can possibly cause a christian not to enter into all that God would have for him, A big question... are you feeding from goth, or feeding from Jesus? i was talking with some big techno/rave christian dj's who work in clubs where there is alot of drugs etc.. about Dark Things.. yes the world is full of darkness, Sin has wrecked havoc in the lives of everybody, and all of creation is groining for the I'm not saying to put on a fakey fakey smile and not be real to our troubles, and struggles, and pains... on the contrary life has suffering, much suffering, christian or nonchristian, but i'm slowly learning something that many christians and matyers you see i can wake up and choose to accept God's forgiveness and "his mercies and new every morning" , and i can be thankful Jesus died, yes he died.. for us for our sins... he suffered all that evil could deal out, and spilt his perfect blood for our sakes.. about being different.. about dying to self..
quote: ART in modern culture , and even democracy etc have often become idols... there is a difference between aknowledging and realizing
quote: the above is true.... jesus did suffer a teribble death for us.. but its not the issue of his 'being dead' that is the gospel..
quote: there is much truth in above.. often i lay on my bed and cry because i know of my sin, i am a man riddled with sin, and i can
quote: it is true that communion has often become a ritual.. and that for somebody to realise the fullness of its meaning and the intesitiy of Christs suffering, can do something for a christian.. it can cause them not to take God's sacrifice lightly and maybe convict them on their sin.. however to institute in our lives just focusing on this aspect on his death and resurrection is to miss the boat the other way.. his death was dark because he took on the sins of the world, however he had victory and we are remembering a few things, (uncomplete list) the fact that he went through so much for our sake, the fact that our sins are forgiven and washed away and that he rose again, its a somber time, but a time of celebration at the same time.. the early church did it as part of there every time they met togeather nd had a meal.. it wasn't some dark ritual, nor some meaningly mild ritual , it was real.. it was remembering and it was celebratory.. it is celebrating that "the darkness cannot snuff out the light"..
quote: Dieing to self is diffierent than self destructive, or self sabotaging behaviours... very different.. one is hurting ourselves for I am not saying we have to be cookie cutter christians... and just because the church fails us and other christians fail us doesn't mean God fails us. God says that he choose the church , in his wisdom, to accomplish His purpose (if i was God i wouldn't have done that.. ) but i trust God's wisedom..
quote: the world is dark, but God's like is so much brighter, even in this fallen world.. the Holy Spirit is indwelling countless amount of people around the globe, and to the measure thatthey are submitting their lives to Christ, He is moving in this age.. (in all cultures and subcultures amen).. its something to be celebratory about (but not in a fake way)... and yes weeping is part of being a christian
quote: honesty is good and needed, the christian church has failed (because its full of people) so much, but the alternative is not
I know my words are jumbed and not so clear and when i say you i was talking to the person who wrote the article not there is much more i would like to say, but i need to get to church now..
please don't get offended at this.. if you get offended ask yourself and God' "why am i getting offended?"... the words i say notes for future posts everybody else can ignore this) ------------------ |
rowanseymour Member Posts: 284 From: Belfast, Northern Ireland Registered: 02-10-2001 |
2 Questions for a Christian Goth... 1. Supposing a stranger passes by you on the street who is in desperate need of something, perhaps money to buy food or his bus ticket home - do you worry that he may be afraid to ask you because of your appearance and the grim look on your face ? 2. Do you feel loved by God ? When I remember how much God loves me and how lucky I am for all the gifts he has given me I want to jump for joy and have little control over the idiotic grin across my face. ------------------ |
Mack Administrator Posts: 2779 From: Registered: 01-20-2001 |
1) Nope 2) Yes, very very much so |
MeanManInOz Member Posts: 388 From: Hobart, Tasmania, Australia Registered: 06-26-2001 |
I think that any sort of labels divide rather than unite, and I'd rather be known only for being a Christian. Before, I had long hair and wore heavy metal T-shirts. I still love metal, but my look is designed to make me approachable by all people, instead of making me seem to belong to only one group. Of course, God looks to the inside, but being 'all things to all men' is a logical extension of spiritual growth, because it's doing what the Bible says. I'm not saying that Christian Goths are unsaved, but that anyone who seeks any label in addition to Christian probably has some growing to do. |
Angel Member Posts: 699 From: The Blissful State Of Me? Registered: 05-21-2001 |
Ok you hit a note I have to speak a bit on. If you dress normal... you frighten me. Most people that dress casual or pritty have been mean and heartliss to me and my friends and my kin. Its fine if you do dress that way. I wouldnt find you aprochibul at all. Infact I would turn and run the other way. (Besides if you look at it my way Politics try to be aprochibal and so do loyers... you see what im saying im sure) -end of line- ------------------ |
MeanManInOz Member Posts: 388 From: Hobart, Tasmania, Australia Registered: 06-26-2001 |
Ok you hit a note I have to speak a bit on. If you dress normal... you frighten me. Most people that dress casual or pritty have been mean and heartliss to me and my friends and my kin. I would think that a lot of people who have NOT been heartless to you also dress 'normal', the point of normal is that most people do it. This speaks again of your seeking fellowship more with a particular human subculture instead of the church. Its fine if you do dress that way. I wouldnt find you aprochibul at all. You wouldn't find me approachable because I don't dress wierd ? You need to stop looking at the outside then, how can you say others do this when you clearly do it also ? I decide if someone is approachable by looking them in the eye and smiling, and seeing how they respond, not by how new or fashionable or 'normal' their clothes are. If we met, it sounds like I would be happy to speak to you, but you would avoid me. Who out of us is looking to the outer man ? Infact I would turn and run the other way. (Besides if you look at it my way Politics try to be aprochibal and so do loyers... you see what im saying im sure) Lawyers and politicians try to be approachable for their own ends, and so do prostitutes. But you can't claim Jesus tried not to be approachable ? you must run a lot, if that's your reaction to anyone who dresses in ordinary clothes. I really feel sorry for you ( seriously ). |
DeaTH Member Posts: 28 From: halletsville Registered: 01-24-2002 |
welp angel took every thing I was going to say.I for one am a goth punk but i dress in the norm but mostly dark's like BLACK i like.but i got this odd fondnes for yellow green and orange Loud colors.And i love the idea of being COVERD IN BLOOOOOOOOOD!!!!!!! HAR HAR HAR thats the blood of jesus ¤The M*** JER* ** **¤ |
Angel Member Posts: 699 From: The Blissful State Of Me? Registered: 05-21-2001 |
Dang you cant be figurtive on the net without someone taking it wrong. Oh well what do I care. Anyways you just said if someone is in a subculture then they need to grow up. Your in a subculture to and so is everyone. I dress the way I do becase I am more aprochibul by kids then. I like youth alot more then old people. Old people are set in their ways most the time and not worth the headake to me. I tend to try and not mess with them. Which is funny cuz im here arguing about this crud with you. Ill probably get flack for posting this too. So lets see clothing bla... I would rather be in a kilt anyways or a toga or a prist rob. Would be alot more comfterbul. Thats what I mainly dress as. The more comfterbul the better. Cloths are ment to cover you up anyways (So why be uncomfterbul)? so lets see what was the point in this post? I forgot... I should be working on game not here with this. NO NO im here to warm up my fingers I forgot. Watashi wa baka na. You know I think we have alot of missunderstandings just cuz this is the net. I bet if I met you in person we could take care of alot of our probs in a simple conversation. Im a blunt and exajerating person. Most everyone knows me as a pain in the butt that gets people to laugh or is in his corner brooding over something. (NICE SPOT OF TEA) yes I do like that, two spoons of sugar for me please! k im gone for now need to work ------------------ |
MeanManInOz Member Posts: 388 From: Hobart, Tasmania, Australia Registered: 06-26-2001 |
Dang you cant be figurtive on the net without someone taking it wrong. So you're saying you WOULDN'T find it hard to approach me then ? Anyways you just said if someone is in a subculture then they need to grow up. Absolutely. Your in a subculture to and so is everyone. Mine is called the church. Beyond that, I do not seek to identify myself by what I do, what music I like or anything else. I seek to make those things irrelevant so that I am known as a Christian, and so that I can be 'all things to all men'. I dress the way I do becase I am more aprochibul by kids then. Rubbish. I am approachable by youth, and I am old. You are possibly more approachable by the subsection of youth that dress like you, but you're also no different to them in their eyes if you present yourself the same as them. I like youth alot more then old people. Old people are set in their ways most the time and not worth the headake to me. A lot of young people are insufferable to me, because they think they know more than they do. But I will make the effort to understand where they are at, rather than judge them. I'm only 33, and I can see how much society has changed since I was young. Imagine how hard that is for someone who is 50, or 70 ? ( by the way, am I old to you ? ) I tend to try and not mess with them. Which is funny cuz im here arguing about this crud with you. Ill probably get flack for posting this too. Well, probably. I think you're taking a selfish view. I have a question - when someone becomes a Christian, why don't they just die so they can enter the new age ? Is it to preach the Gospel ? To all people, or just those we have a lot in common with ? So lets see clothing bla... I would rather be in a kilt anyways or a toga or a prist rob. Would be alot more comfterbul. Thats what I mainly dress as. The more comfterbul the better. Cloths are ment to cover you up anyways (So why be uncomfterbul)? so lets see what was the point in this post? I forgot... I should be working on game not here with this. I prefer to be comfortable, in fact if I can work from home I tend not to wear anything ( sorry for the mental image ). I find jeans comfortable, and I find a suit comfortable, but that is just me. The point is not to have to wear a suit, or jeans, or anything else, but to choose something that does not turn people away from you, or the Gospel. NO NO im here to warm up my fingers I forgot. Watashi wa baka na. You know I think we have alot of missunderstandings just cuz this is the net. I bet if I met you in person we could take care of alot of our probs in a simple conversation. Absolutely - it's always hard to talk online, even in a chat program, let alone a board like this. Im a blunt and exajerating person. Nothing wrong with being blunt a lot of the time, but I find it hard to tell when you are exaggerating. BTW have you noticed that I try to use words that you have spelled wrong ? Just trying to help :-) |
Klumsy Administrator Posts: 1061 From: Port Angeles, WA, USA Registered: 10-25-2001 |
angel you are not a baka/fool.. ------------------ |
Angel Member Posts: 699 From: The Blissful State Of Me? Registered: 05-21-2001 |
Tanks Klumsy MeanOz I say "Bla bla bla to you" and a happy new year I have to work and this is going no where. You wont see anymore post from me here nore will I come back to this page to read anything so that I wont be tempted to post on this.
Angel ------------------ |
MeanManInOz Member Posts: 388 From: Hobart, Tasmania, Australia Registered: 06-26-2001 |
quote: I bet you do read this :-) Anyhow, I'm sorry you have no response for what I am trying to say, and that you seem to percieve I am trying to attack you - I am not. I'd like to point out some fundamental truths, but the point is to encourage you in good, not to attack you. |
DeaTH Member Posts: 28 From: halletsville Registered: 01-24-2002 |
hey come as you r who realy gives a dang what you look like i dont care if you look like adalf hitler just as long as your saved man are you people that dins "rolls his eyes and gets a whatever look" |
MeanManInOz Member Posts: 388 From: Hobart, Tasmania, Australia Registered: 06-26-2001 |
quote: Did you mean are, really, adolf, you're, dense ? Punctuation also helps make your posts readable. Anyhow, the way someone looks has nothing to do with salvation, God isn't coming back for only middle class people by any stretch of the imagination. My point is more that if people are saved out of the world, then why do they want to identify with worldly subcultures, and how does this equate to being 'all things to all men' ? Sure, there is variation in the church, we are all individuals, but I think people who go to extremes to be 'different' from average people in how they look and act have obviously missed something about what the church is about. |
Mack Administrator Posts: 2779 From: Registered: 01-20-2001 |
^ Some of us don't do this just to stick out of the crowd. I do this because personality wise I am very different from alot of people, it's not so I can shock people with my shaved head, black nails, dark poetry and dark clothes, it's because I'm lead to it. I feel free in it, I can express myself, have a deeper relationship with God and my Fiance and alot more things. |
MeanManInOz Member Posts: 388 From: Hobart, Tasmania, Australia Registered: 06-26-2001 |
quote: Lead by what ? Your relationship with God is made deeper by painting your nails black ? I'm struggling to understand this. As an ex-head banger ( i.e. still love the music but no longer dress the part ), I am intensely amused by the fact that people in these sub cultures think they are expressing their individuality when in fact they are subject to far stricter mores than the mainstream. As an example, when Metallica bought out the Load album, very little was said about how they went from metal to alternative, and much was said about how they cut their hair. A metal band with short hair ? Unthinkable !!! Anyhow, I am seriously trying to understand all of this, I'd love to know how you feel your relationship with God is enhanced by your pursuit of a worldly subculture. |
Mack Administrator Posts: 2779 From: Registered: 01-20-2001 |
My entire life I've been squashed by Christians by expressing myself, I have a deep understanding of things, for those people it was wrong to express my love and excitement for God the way I did, I was squashed into following the man-made rules and regulations of religion. This eventually turned me away from God and turned me off from Christianity and Christians for several years. When God heard my cries in the night he sent who is now my Fiancé, and through her God worked miracles in me. I ditched the church after 10 years of spiritual pain, starvation and tormenting. I swore never to listen to what anyone (or any subcultures or cultures) had to say when it comes to myself and how I have a relationship with God. You have it backwards, my relationship with God isn't enhanced when I paint my nails black, I paint my nails black because God is bringing out the part of me that was squashed for all those years. I am only running towards God, while this is happening He's bringing what I can say the real me out and that brings me even closer to Him. |
DeaTH Member Posts: 28 From: halletsville Registered: 01-24-2002 |
being all things for all men huh well im being a goth HAR HAR HAR HAHAHAHAHAHA |
DeaTH Member Posts: 28 From: halletsville Registered: 01-24-2002 |
hey did i ever tell you im supposed to raise the dead very odd i think but a man that came to chuch told me this |
MeanManInOz Member Posts: 388 From: Hobart, Tasmania, Australia Registered: 06-26-2001 |
quote: I'm sorry, but all of this is in your mind. I am sorry you've been oppressed by narrow minded people, but I doubt God wants to bring out the part of you that stops you obeying part of the Bible. I'm not saying your personality has to change, or the music you like, or the sort of things that interest you, only that in the Gospel such things run a distant third to Christ. When I was saved all I wore was heavy metal t-shirts. You know the thing - demons, skulls, anything 'evil' looking. I still like that sort of music ( although I have my whole life drawn the line at music that sings against God or for the Devil, such as Slayer or Marilyn Manson ), but I stopped wearing the T-shirts because right or wrong, I don't want people to discount my message by what I look like. The problem is theirs, not mine, but I'm more interested in seeing souls saved, or at least the Gospel represented faithfully than in 'expressing myself' by an extreme appearance which would bring Christ into disrepute. |
MeanManInOz Member Posts: 388 From: Hobart, Tasmania, Australia Registered: 06-26-2001 |
quote: I'm sorry that you clearly have some issues. Does this mean you're not a Christian, or that you think what the Bible says is a joke ? |
Mack Administrator Posts: 2779 From: Registered: 01-20-2001 |
*sigh* Oz you have to be joking me with the post you made to me. Stop being so bloody stubborn and open up to what I'm saying, being the way I am is the way I've always been (until I was crushed for 10 years by people like yourself), I've been able to reach out to so many people because of what God is doing in my life with bringing my personality out. If you can't get this right "in your mind", then I'm going to stop the conversation entirely because it's a worthless conversation that will just bring me to dislike you strongly, and I don't want that at all. I have no idea where you get all this stuff from me being more separate from God and disobeying the Bible because I'm growing into God and God is working through me, healing me and training me. You can't have any objective word in how God is expanding in my life because you have no idea what's happened in my life and you can't tell God how to work in some ones life and if it's God or not! It's not your way or the highway Oz, stop being so legalistic, God can't reach out to people who are so blind set in their own ways which they think is "right". I'm not pressuring my views on anyone and your leaping all over me like I'm a spawn of satan, settle down man, you are not right, you have the issue. |
MeanManInOz Member Posts: 388 From: Hobart, Tasmania, Australia Registered: 06-26-2001 |
quote: You're saying that through expressing yourself in this way, you're becoming more outgoing and able to speak to people ?
quote: I'm just trying to point out that the Bible says to be judged for nothing but the Gospel, to make sure we are blameless in every other part of our lives. I have also been careful to point out that is someone judges you by how you look, they have the problem. The point I am making is not that you are wrong, but that you should love the unsaved enough to be willing to change even though they are wrong, to make you better able to present the Gospel to them. I've also been careful to say I'm not suggesting you need to look middle class, but that the image I get from what you're saying is a lot more extreme than I would consider wise, and that I speak from my own experience.
quote: You obviously take your appearance far to personally to discuss it - when I thought I was a Christian but didn't have the Holy Spirit I was the same about my 'look'. I realise now I was hiding behind it, and when I recieved the Holy Spirit, speaking in tongues, part of the instant change in my life was to not care what I looked like, and to be confident to deal with people in my life, including people I did not know. To recap - in my life, I knew that God accepted me for what I was inside, and I would always look to know people before coming to any conclusions based on anything as transient as clothing or hair. However, I also realised that the people who had witnessed to me had come to a point where they thought I would drift away without obeying the Gospel, because I looked like such a rough nut. Such a look would not inspire people to take me seriously, or to believe what I have to say about God or salvation. Even though I knew they had the problem there, I changed my look of my own accord to be something more useful to God. I am still able to speak to people who look a bit extreme, usually the fact that I am willing to approach them is enough to break the barrier they may percieve by my lack of a particular hairstyle. I can also speak to older people who would have trouble looking through my hair or clothes if I looked now the way I used to. |
Mack Administrator Posts: 2779 From: Registered: 01-20-2001 |
quote: I'm saying that now that my personality is more outwards and that God is working on bringing it out even more and working on it, that I'm not afriad to talk to people about God and issues related to them. If God wants me to change the way I look then I will, I see a whole world of unreached to teens/adults that I can talk and relate to and they're not afriad of me and I'm not afriad of them. I'm not going to be stubborn and keep the way I look and defy God if He tells me to change. However I'm not going to change if a Christian comes up to me and says "I don't like the way you look, you dress in dark clothes and look evil!". I have some self esteeme issues from time to time with my looks, but that's about it. |
Klumsy Administrator Posts: 1061 From: Port Angeles, WA, USA Registered: 10-25-2001 |
meanman, I know mack some, not so well, but enough to know his heart and his heart for God.. I disagree with him on some stuff,and he with me.. i don't think he is overly goth, though as in my original long post, i pointed out some 'danger' or be aware points.. I personally am thankful for macks friendship and accountibility in my life, and though his poetry may be full with dark words sometimes, it potrays some deep truths about Christ of GOd.. i personally believe that as he grows deeper with Christ his outlook will change some , more towards the light, but also he won't fall into the trap of being nicey nicey fakey fakey. I think he has some areas to grow in with relationships with all strata of peoples, but so do I and i am sure you do also meanman.. its life.. and I believe that as he grows in that his worldview will become more balanced (at the moment i think its still healthily balanced )... anyhow i appreciate the friendship and heart of this man of God.
quote: as for you my friend, this is one such area that you can take to God and grow.. when we swear anything, its dangerous , because we close up that area in our lives for God to deal with. so as a friend, i would encourage you to open your heart to this issue.. for when you swear like that, its full of rebellion.. i know its just a defense mechanism and i close up in similar ways, but the bible says that listening to people and cousellers is wise.. you don't have to accept curses that people may judge over your life, but i think being vulnerable is an important thing.. it means you will be hurt, but its definately worth it (ie especially in marriage, i get more hurt when i am vulnerble to my wife, but the rewards in quality of relationship and fulliment is awesome), any its worth it to listen to people, don't just accept a curse, but you can take the things away and submit the words (even if hurtful) and your heart and your attitudes at the foot of Christ.. love Karl ------------------ |
MeanManInOz Member Posts: 388 From: Hobart, Tasmania, Australia Registered: 06-26-2001 |
quote: I am always concerned when people are waiting for God to 'tell' them stuff he already has told them (in the Bible), but I think Karl has put a nice end to this thread, so maybe we'll just leave it at that. It's obvious that I can't understand your world-view, because mine is of recieving the Holy Spirit and having the issues you raise all healed in one defining moment, and that you can't distinguish between what I am saying and someone judging you by your appearance. |
Klumsy Administrator Posts: 1061 From: Port Angeles, WA, USA Registered: 10-25-2001 |
meanman it is true that we can often try to hear certain aspects from God when he has already given us the path to walk in the meantime.. but i don't think that is the always the case.. meanman, ------------------ |
Mack Administrator Posts: 2779 From: Registered: 01-20-2001 |
Karl is right, I have to grow in trusting more people (which is hard), I just didn't want to hurt anymore. |
MeanManInOz Member Posts: 388 From: Hobart, Tasmania, Australia Registered: 06-26-2001 |
quote: *grin* I have in the past not wanted to name where I go for two reasons. The first is that I am more interested in discussing the Bible than church denominations. The second is that the church I belong to is the subject of much misinformation online, only yesterday I was wondering if I should laugh or cry as I read all sorts of outragous lies on some cult site that named us, presumably on the say so of a disgruntled ex-member, which is much like asking Pauline Hanson about the Liberal Party IMO. Anyhow, yes, yes, and yes. |
DeaTH Member Posts: 28 From: halletsville Registered: 01-24-2002 |
NO I DONOT think the Bible is a joke i just feel your only looking at that part of the bible in one way |
MeanManInOz Member Posts: 388 From: Hobart, Tasmania, Australia Registered: 06-26-2001 |
quote: Fair enough. I look at this verse in a number of (mutually compatible) ways, but there's only one way in which it applies to this topic IMO. I'd be willing to listen if you believe I am misappropriating it. |
D-SIPL Moderator Posts: 1345 From: Maesteg, Wales Registered: 07-21-2001 |
There has been a lot of different opinions expressed on this on this board. I must say that i'm still not convinced that there can be a "Christian Goth" (but don't start flaming me, it's just my personal opinion). Anyways it's seems that people from different denominations have different beliefs on the subject. --D-SIPL |
MadProf Member Posts: 181 From: Larnaka, Cyprus Registered: 01-24-2001 |
Um... Being a christian should have nothing to do with what music you listen to or how you dress. As I understand it, being a christian means you believe in Jesus. I dont want to start turning this topic into a speaking in toungues/vs not convo again, but that is *my* take on it. MMIO: If, because I have not spoken in toungues, that means I have not been "filled" with the Holy Spirit, so be it. I trust God enough that I know that if/when God wants me to be, he'll tell me, and these conversations and arguments aren't helping me at all. Thanks, I apreciate you wanting to help me, and God knows your heart. I've thought a great deal more about lots of things than I would have had you not been here! :-D But I believe I AM a christian. Anyone can say I'm not, if they want, I dont mind. I am also a vegitarian. Some people will no doubt say "how can this be? the disciples ate meat and fish! So did Jesus!". True. However, being a vegitarian is because I (a) dont like the taste of meat and (b) dont like the idea. I think it is 99.99% impossible that the disciples listened to goth music, but I also doubt if they listened to mozart. This doesn't mean either are wrong. Anyways, I dont think I meant to say all that much. Anyways, I hope this message doesn't spark off an argument. If it does, just blaim me. :-D Dan ------------------ |
MeanManInOz Member Posts: 388 From: Hobart, Tasmania, Australia Registered: 06-26-2001 |
quote: I agree with the former, to a point. However, my point was that part of *walking* as a Christian means not needing worldly subcultures, regardless of what music we like, and continue to like/listen to, and certainly not seeking to identify oneself with anything apart from Christ that could divide.
quote: The thing is, God HAS told you - you own a Bible, yes ? Why should He appear before you and tell you what it says ? The Bible indicates He sends His servants to present His message.
quote: I NEVER said that listening to goth music ( whatever that is ) is wrong, or evil. I like heavy metal, for goodness sakes !!! On another front, if you ARE a Christian, then none of my posts will change that, and the reverse is also true. Hence the need to make sure we've got it right from the only source that matters, i.e. the Bible. |
MadProf Member Posts: 181 From: Larnaka, Cyprus Registered: 01-24-2001 |
meanman: sorry if i sounded like i was ranting at you... I didn't mean to! *sighs* I think i've gone and put my foot (size 12) in my mouth again. This does not bode well about the size of mine mouth. I'm making a fool of myself. I'm sorry. I shouldn't have joined this thread. ------------------ |
MeanManInOz Member Posts: 388 From: Hobart, Tasmania, Australia Registered: 06-26-2001 |
s'alright. Too many 'churches' want to turn people into middle class white collar workers who like muzak, so it's not surprising that my statements could be misinterpreted in this way, or that people would feel defensive against such a view. |