General Christian Discussions

the neccesity of tounges – klumsy

Klumsy

Administrator

Posts: 1061
From: Port Angeles, WA, USA
Registered: 10-25-2001
quote:
Originally posted by MeanManInOz:
First of all we are all brothers and I do not wish to argue
or be proven right.

Because you and I say so, or because God says so ? I wish it were the case...


you think we aren't brothers in Christ.. search for Brother in a bible in the NT , there will be countless.

quote:
Originally posted by MeanManInOz:

This is a straw man. I never said the gifts save us, they are the outward manifestation of the salvation made possible by Christ's death & resurrection.


I am sorry, i assumed you were coming that tounges was a prerequisite of being a 'real christian'. i misunderstood you.
please forgive me.

quote:
Originally posted by MeanManInOz:

while tounges (other than in public cases where there is an interpretation, and cool miracles where you are speaking somebodies tounge and preaching to them unaware) is for individual edification..

That's true - are you saying not all Christians need to be edified ?

[/B]



no but the scripture doesn't say thats the only way to be edified, just like eating a banana isn't the only thing a man can eat.
I have not the time to go into a study of the greek word **************


quote:
Originally posted by MeanManInOz:

being without tounges is like being without dimention.. if you
are deaf you live without the dimention of sound... and being able to hear improves your ability to live..
tounges is like that..
however its not a prerequisite...

Goodness me, read that again and try to believe it.



do you mean it sounds like a load of hogwash? (it is a stretched analogy) or you mean its right on
and i need to read what i wrote and believe it? I do... like paul says "i speak in tounges more than all of you"
i am a tounges speaking penticostal, am in to prophecy in a big way, laying on of hands , etc , i've hung out with people
who have raised people from the dead, seen amazing miracles of healing (even physical stuff on the outside etc)..

I believe, my only point is that tounges isn't the beginning or end of christian spirituality.. I know people who have prophecied much,
layed on hands and healed, even intepreted tounges, though never uttered a word of tounges in their own life.. maybe if some cases
it may have been that they were not surrendering their whole will to God and recieving His gift, but i don't think in all the cases


quote:
Originally posted by MeanManInOz:
many of the greatest saints of Christ lived without tounges, some because of ignorance, and others because God didn't bestow it upon them..

You may feel the right to bestow sainthood ( yes I know it means being a Christian, no more, no less ), but I prefer to let God do that.


I didn't mean to bestoy sainthood.. i'm not saying the popes list of best saints... paul called other christians saints.. and yes
only God knows the heart of man... let me say even men, who by their consistant and good fruit (in works, in love, in displaying
of spiritual gifts), such men that the majority of christiandom (spanning the denomination or not) has noted to be men who
walked with God, and submited their lives to God and were used greatly by God.

Of this group, many did not speak in tounges..
and they are Christians..
you implied in your comment to rowan , when saying that he knew christians and should have them pray with Him, that he
wasn't one.. I know this man, this is a man , though young in the faith, isn't living a life of religion , he is involved in a church
that goes after spiritual gifts, and a man whom has a heart for God (of course only God knows our hearts, and the heart of
man is full of inequity, buts God's grace is sufficent), He claims to be saved, just as you and i do, without the slightever wavering
like the waves on the sea, if his faith had been weaker such a comment could had indeed wounded a young christian.
He did not take it personally, and i know at times i have said things that i shouldn't have, some that have driven people from Christ,
and my heart has agonised over that fact, but God's grace is sufficent... anyhow.. i am not codemning you , just saying..
for there is no condemnation in Christ.. whether you are defensive or not, or whether you think its just a misunderstanding or
go to God and realise that there is something in your heart to let God deal with, is between you and God in your quite times..
May God guides us all in his truth, for our rightouesness is like filthy tampons to him (its graphic but thats what dirty rags means in the greek, menstrual clothes).... I am no more right than you, my friend, we are each in need of God's mercy and grace, and
we each are fighting a battle to take up our cross daily and surrender to the Lordship of Christ in every area of our lives, in all our
attitudes etc..

quote:
Originally posted by MeanManInOz:

Perfect Love is not wishy washy.. rowans whole message was just a quote from the bible..

He posted three, I was replying to them all and my 'wishy washy' comment was in response to the manifestation of compassion being different to human compassion.


sorry about that, another misunderstanding on my part... so many words and messages to cruise through... and web BBS's
aren't the bestway to talk, yet use..

quote:
Originally posted by MeanManInOz:
The holy spirit can inspire you to speak words irregardless of tounges.... What about all those scriptures that say
"when you are taken to court to give an account for me etc etc, don't worry what to say because the Holy Spirit will help you speak"

Of course, I never said otherwise. Do you contend the Spirit only does this in the lives of some believers ? The ones who cannot speak in tongues ?


no i don't i contend, the Spirit can use either way, or both.. not exclusive in any way. His ways are higher than mine as a man
and in my lifetime i won't come close to putting Him in my box of human understanding and capibility of my finiteness.

quote:
Originally posted by MeanManInOz:
You can't take that one scripture and build a doctrne that says :to proclaim jesus and be saved one must proclaim it in tounges..

How can you say that when I posted a body of scripture, most of it as yet unanswered. Do you mean my comment on 1 Cor 12:2 (ish) ? You tell me what it means then - I asked for alternative interpretations that make sense. I'm yet to hear one, here or anywhere.


sorry for my assumption of one scripture.. i just just talking about what was on the table at the moment. my wrong..

oh my understanding of 1 cor 12:3

quote:
1 corinthians 12:3 (KJV)
Wherefore I give you to understand, that no man speaking by the Spirit of God calleth Jesus accursed: and that no man can say that Jesus is the Lord, but by the Holy Ghost.
New Living Translation
So I want you to know how to discern what is truly from God: No one speaking by the Spirit of God can curse Jesus, and no one is able to say, "Jesus is Lord," except by the Holy Spirit.
(NIV )
Therefore I tell you that no one who is speaking by the Spirit of God says, "Jesus be cursed," and no one can say, "Jesus is Lord," except by the Holy Spirit.


Ok the first thing and most broadest understanding is that that no man can say that Jesus is Lord without the help of the holy spirit.
So first level on intepretation .. would be that one would have to be saved, and thus have the Holy Spirit residing in one
to testify that Jesus is lord, and having said that, on the other hand you can't accurse Jesus if you do have the holy spirit..

The positive thing says 'by the Holy spirit', the negative thing says 'speaking by the spirit of God'... if you interpret speaking by
the Spirit of God to exculsively mean by tounges.(which i disagree with). that would say that no man could curse God in tounges... which is probably true.

however that doesn't say that saying that Jesus is the Lord is only capible of by tounges, it just says by the Holy Spirit..
The Holy spirit can lead us other than by tounges.. He helps us defend our faith in front of courts etc, in a real language too.
that is By the Holy Spirit.. and also speaking...

another wording i've heard before is that no one can really say that "Jesus is Lord" (other than just words, like the scripture that
says 'not all that call me Lord, will enter the kingdom).. anyway to really testify that Jesus is Lord has to be inspired and shown
by the Holy Spirit, in our human ability we can't testify the truth of that.. but being saved by the holy spirit we can..
Just like when Jesus asked Peter who he thought he was.. and Peter said "you are the messiah" and Jesus said that
man had not revealed that to peter but the holy spirit..

thats my interpretation , now for some of biblical scholars, whom are much more versed in the bible than I..

http://bible.crosswalk.com/Commentaries/GillsExpositionoftheBible/gil.cgi?book=1co&chapter=12&verse=3 to get the historical
context..
He mentions that even the demons know and can say the Jesus is Lord ,

and quote

quote:

but by the Spirit; since such an appropriation includes spiritual knowledge of Christ, strong affection to him; faith of interest in him, an hearty profession of him, and sincere subjection to him; all which cannot be without the Spirit of God: for he is the spirit of wisdom and revelation in the knowledge of him; and true love to Christ is a genuine fruit of his; faith in Christ, is entirely of his operation; and a subjection to the righteousness of Christ, and to his ordinances, is through the influence of his grace; and it is owing to his witnessings that any can truly, and in faith, claim their interest in him. Upon the whole, the apostle's sense is, let a man pretend to what he will, if he does not love Jesus Christ, and believe in him, he is destitute of his Spirit; and whoever loves Christ, and believes in him, and can call him his Lord in faith and fear, however mean otherwise his gifts may be, he is a partaker of the Spirit of God.

from the geneva study bible

quote:

(3) The conclusion: know you therefore that you cannot so much as move your lips to honour Christ at all, except by the grace of the Holy Spirit.


http://bible.crosswalk.com/Commentaries/JamiesonFaussetBrown/jfb.cgi?book=1co&chapter=12#1Co12_3
speaking . . . say--"Speak" implies the act of utterance; "say" refers to that which is uttered. Here, "say" means a spiritual and believing confession of Him.
from matthew henry consise commentary the following :
quote:
While heathens, they had not been influenced by the Spirit of Christ. No man can call Christ Lord, with believing dependence upon him, unless that faith is wrought by the Holy Ghost. No man could believe with his heart, or prove by a miracle, that Jesus was Christ, unless by the Holy Ghost.


from peoples n.t
quote:

3. Spiritual gifts. The supernatural gifts bestowed in the early church by the Spirit. These were especially needful, before the church had the New Testament as a guide, and in the inauguration of Christianity. 2. Ye were Gentiles, carried away unto these dumb idols. Idolaters worshiping idols. These false gods had oracles, and priests professed to speak under the influence of the spirit of the god. The oracle of Delphos, not far distant from Corinth, was especially celebrated. 3. No man speaking by the spirit of God, etc. How should they test those professing to speak by the divine Spirit? If a heathen priest professed to speak by the spirit and called Jesus accursed, he had not the Spirit of God. In times of persecution Christians were asked to say Jesus Anathema. If one speaking by the spirit pronounced Jesus the Lord, he had the Holy Spirit. This confession from the heart is always moved by the Spirit.


some intepretatons from ages past to recent..
and back to my toughts, i do not believe that this scirputre that says 'speaking by the spirit of God' means in tounges, though
i am a tounges speaking Christian and would not wish to not have that gift, as the edificcation i recieved due to it in immense
and i am thankful.. however i don't believe that you can read into this scripture to say that all christians speak tounges
especially in the context of this scripture... then follow down to verse 7 - 10

quote:
2nd corithians 12: 7 - 12 (KJV)

Now to each one the manifestation of the Spirit is given for the common good. To one there is given through the Spirit the message of wisdom, to another the message of knowledge by means of the same Spirit, to another faith by the same Spirit, to another gifts of healing by that one Spirit, to another miraculous powers, to another prophecy, to another distinguishing between spirits, to another speaking in different kinds of tongues, and to still another the interpretation of tongues. All these are the work of one and the same Spirit, and he gives them to each one, just as he determines. The body is a unit, though it is made up of many parts; and though all its parts are many, they form one body. So it is with Christ.




which says that to ONe person is given a certian gift, and to another yet a different gift... and the body made of christians
execersings their different gifts and ministries work togeather for the purpose of Christ..
so not all christians may speak in tounges... and God doesn't require it.. its something that is good... very good..
and i believe that if you ask God for this gift , he'll ussually give it to you...
but not all christians speak in tounges..

May everyone be blessed with odedience to God in your life.. (me included)

------------------
Karl Prosser
Karl / GODCENTRIC
Klumsy / Surprise ! Productions.
ME / Redeemed by the Living God :)
Klumsy@xtra.co.nz
May God Bless you, he sure does me.

Angel

Member

Posts: 699
From: The Blissful State Of Me?
Registered: 05-21-2001
I do not wish to get deep into this disctuion. Least ways not right now im to tired for it. I just wanted to say that in the Bible Paul also said that all the gifts are nothing without Love. The Holy Spirit also gives many gifts. The one I am most after is "Peace". I do not speak in toungs becase I am not lead to. I am however lead by the Spirit when I studie and when I speak to many people. Scriptures that I have well forgoten just pop right out of me. Still the point of this posting is simply to state that if Love is not in what you are doing then what is the point? 1 Corinthians chapter 13 is what love is. I often ask myself if I am acting in Love or if I am just bosting my own openions to justifie my own point of view. Tungues and Prophecy and anything else is meaningliss if you have not Love. Take this as you will but I am only asking that if you are going to do something do it out of Love. Anyways im getting to tired to go on. God made us that we need sleep and im going to go get me some ^_^ Hope you guys come out to a good conclution without getting carpotonal sindrom in your hands from typing to much at one time

------------------
Peaza Cheez Mates!
Azariah "Angel"

Klumsy

Administrator

Posts: 1061
From: Port Angeles, WA, USA
Registered: 10-25-2001
exactly

------------------
Karl Prosser
Karl / GODCENTRIC
Klumsy / Surprise ! Productions.
ME / Redeemed by the Living God :)
Klumsy@xtra.co.nz
May God Bless you, he sure does me.

MeanManInOz
Member

Posts: 388
From: Hobart, Tasmania, Australia
Registered: 06-26-2001
quote:

you think we aren't brothers in Christ.. search for Brother in a bible in the NT , there will be countless.

Yes, I have countless brothers, the defining thing being not the church they belong to, but the fact that they have obeyed God and therefore can speak in tongues. Those who have the gift and claim it is a bolt on extra like mag wheels on a car are the wayward sons of the family, but they are still brothers.


quote:

I am sorry, i assumed you were coming that tounges was a prerequisite of being a 'real christian'. i misunderstood you.
please forgive me.

Well, all Christians speak in tongues, I did say that. What I didn't say was that the gift of tongues was the focus of salvation. Christ's death and resurrection is.


quote:

no but the scripture doesn't say thats the only way to be edified, just like eating a banana isn't the only thing a man can eat.
I have not the time to go into a study of the greek word **************

1 Cor 14 says tongues is how we pray in the Spirit, and Jude says this builds us in the faith and keeps us in Gods love. Accepting it's only one way to build oneself up, if it's not important why did God create it, and if it is worthwhile, why do you think God gives with partiality ?


quote:

like paul says "i speak in tounges more than all of you"

Great - now you need to preach the Gospel as well as having recieved it. As for my comment regarding what you said, you basically said tongues rule, a Christain without tongues is one dimensional, then you said in the same breath that it's not such a big deal.

Actually, Paul said 'I thank my God I speak with tonuges more than you all'. As you know how much you SIT is entirely up to you, and Paul couldn't have known how much those in Corinth used the gift. He isn't saying he SIT more than them, he's saying he is more thankful to God for the gift than them all.


quote:

I didn't mean to bestoy sainthood.. i'm not saying the popes list of best saints... paul called other christians saints..

I know, I clarified that as well. My point was that you are bestowing salvation on people who do not have the sign Jesus identified with salvation.


quote:

let me say even men, who by their consistant and good fruit (in works, in love, in displaying of spiritual gifts), such men that the majority of christiandom (spanning the denomination or not) has noted to be men who
walked with God, and submited their lives to God and were used greatly by God. Of this group, many did not speak in tounges.. and they are Christians..

There you go again - Christians because you say so, or God says so. If I say they are not, and you say they are, does that matter to their standing with God ? What matters is not what you or I say, but what He has said.

By the way, you tied salvation to works above. Love, i.e. being a nice person to others, is also works.

quote:

sorry about that, another misunderstanding on my part... so many words and messages to cruise through... and web BBS's
aren't the bestway to talk, yet use..

That's OK, agreed this is a hard way to try and talk about things.


quote:

Ok the first thing and most broadest understanding is that that no man can say that Jesus is Lord without the help of the holy spirit.
So first level on intepretation .. would be that one would have to be saved, and thus have the Holy Spirit residing in one
to testify that Jesus is lord, and having said that, on the other hand you can't accurse Jesus if you do have the holy spirit..

By this claim if the Devil says the words 'Jesus is Lord' he will be saved. If I pay someone here $50 to say the words 'Jesus is Lord', they will be saved. I guarentee you that we both have the ability to control our mouths to the point of saying 'I curse Jesus'. I would not say it, but I also would not expect that saying it would immediately bankrupt my salvation.

quote:

The positive thing says 'by the Holy spirit', the negative thing says 'speaking by the spirit of God'... if you interpret speaking by
the Spirit of God to exculsively mean by tounges.(which i disagree with). that would say that no man could curse God in tounges... which is probably true.

Haven't you had the JW's ask you how you know you don't curse Jesus in tongues if you can't understand what you say ? I don't mean that one only speaks 'by the Spirit' in tongues, but that is obviously the context of the three chapters coming, so my interperation is both in context, and means something real that needs to be pointed out.

quote:

however that doesn't say that saying that Jesus is the Lord is only capible of by tounges, it just says by the Holy Spirit..
The Holy spirit can lead us other than by tounges.. He helps us defend our faith in front of courts etc, in a real language too.
that is By the Holy Spirit.. and also speaking...

I agree totally, but that is not the context of these verses.

quote:

another wording i've heard before is that no one can really say that "Jesus is Lord" (other than just words, like the scripture that
says 'not all that call me Lord, will enter the kingdom).. anyway to really testify that Jesus is Lord has to be inspired and shown
by the Holy Spirit, in our human ability we can't testify the truth of that.. but being saved by the holy spirit we can..
Just like when Jesus asked Peter who he thought he was.. and Peter said "you are the messiah" and Jesus said that
man had not revealed that to peter but the holy spirit..

But if the end result is the same ( the words are spoken ), how do we tell the difference ? Refer again to Acts 8 - baptised believers who do not have the Holy Spirit. How did they know ?

quote:

which says that to ONe person is given a certian gift, and to another yet a different gift... and the body made of christians
execersings their different gifts and ministries work togeather for the purpose of Christ..
so not all christians may speak in tounges... and God doesn't require it.. its something that is good... very good..
and i believe that if you ask God for this gift , he'll ussually give it to you...
but not all christians speak in tounges..

I've already pointed out that above the verse you quoted it says there are many gifts but on manifestation that is given to all. In Acts 8 they had faith and healing, so how could they not have the Spirit if your reading of 1 Cor 12 means they had the manifestation of the Spirit ?

Angel:

quote:

just wanted to say that in the Bible Paul also said that all the gifts are nothing without Love.

Absolutely, but that does not mean the gifts are worthless, only that they need to be used with the right attitude. Interestingly Paul doesn't make any provision for people not having the gifts, only that they may not use them properly.

quote:

I do not speak in toungs becase I am not lead to.

That's because you're not being lead. The Bible offers you this gift, and all the others. Do you also claim not to be lead to pray to be healed ? Do you claim not to be lead to have faith ? If you want to throw out one of the gifts, you need to be prepared to throw them all out.

Ultimately if you believe tongues is the sign of the Spirit or not, the fact that you CAN speak in tongues should be enough to make you want to, if you really love God. The same is true of any gift He offers.

Klumsy

Administrator

Posts: 1061
From: Port Angeles, WA, USA
Registered: 10-25-2001
quote:
Originally posted by MeanManInOz:
quote:

you think we aren't brothers in Christ.. search for Brother in a bible in the NT , there will be countless.

Yes, I have countless brothers, the defining thing being not the church they belong to, but the fact that they have obeyed God and therefore can speak in tongues. Those who have the gift and claim it is a bolt on extra like mag wheels on a car are the wayward sons of the family, but they are still brothers.


so anybody who doesn't speak in tounges isn't a true christian nor a brother in your understanding?

but i am (just) because even though i speak in tounges, i don't go so far as to say that if that all born again believers filled
with the Holy Spirit , speak in tounges?


quote:

I am sorry, i assumed you were coming that tounges was a prerequisite of being a 'real christian'. i misunderstood you. please forgive me.
Originally posted by MeanManInOz:
Well, all Christians speak in tongues, I did say that. What I didn't say was that the gift of tongues was the focus of salvation. Christ's death and resurrection is.



amen to Jesus's death and resurrection not being the focus of salvation.. so you are saying in your udnerstanding.. that all Christians speak in tounges , then if you don't speak in Tounges you aren't a christian?

quote:
Originally posted by MeanManInOz:
1 Cor 14 says tongues is how we pray in the Spirit, and Jude says this builds us in the faith and keeps us in Gods love. Accepting it's only one way to build oneself up, if it's not important why did God create it, and if it is worthwhile, why do you think God gives with partiality ?

I belive we can Pray in the Spirit, and means in tounges... but tounges isn't the only way we interact with God or the only way the Holy Spirit interacts with us..
it is worthwhile, it is important... but its not something that determines who is a Christian and who isn't , as you said in other places God knows that
only God knows the heart... there are clear scriptures that say what one needs to 'do' to be saved.. though only God knows ones heart and true motives yada yada
but there is no clear scripture that says "all christians (aka those who are saved) speak in tounges", that is a cultist heresy..


quote:

like paul says "i speak in tounges more than all of you"


Great - now you need to preach the Gospel as well as having recieved it. As for my comment regarding what you said, you basically said tongues rule, a Christain without tongues is one dimensional, then you said in the same breath that it's not such a big deal.

Actually, Paul said 'I thank my God I speak with tonuges more than you all'. As you know how much you SIT is entirely up to you, and Paul couldn't have known how much those in Corinth used the gift. He isn't saying he SIT more than them, he's saying he is more thankful to God for the gift than them all.



SIT? huh? how could have he not known.. many of pauls letters were to teach young believers who hadn't solid truth backing them up and were going
down various paths of heresy, he was correcting and admonishing them in love, and he understood the situations often.. from noticing the situation
and also from the impression on teh Holy Spirit giving words of knowledge etc to Him, the same Holy Spirit that lived in him and gave him the ability to speak in Tounges..
if you study the historical and cultural context of this scripture, and read broadly from those who are well versed in the bible and those original languages etc
you can find that out..
I don't say tounges is not a big deal, i wouldn't want to be without it.. However its just one manifestation of the Holy Spirit...

quote:

I didn't mean to bestoy sainthood.. i'm not saying the popes list of best saints... paul called other christians saints..

I know, I clarified that as well. My point was that you are bestowing salvation on people who do not have the sign Jesus identified with salvation.


so were the apostles saved before or at pentecost? ...


quote:

let me say even men, who by their consistant and good fruit (in works, in love, in displaying of spiritual gifts), such men that the majority of christiandom (spanning the denomination or not) has noted to be men who
walked with God, and submited their lives to God and were used greatly by God. Of this group, many did not speak in tounges.. and they are Christians..

There you go again - Christians because you say so, or God says so. If I say they are not, and you say they are, does that matter to their standing with God ? What matters is not what you or I say, but what He has said.

By the way, you tied salvation to works above. Love, i.e. being a nice person to others, is also works.



only God knows there hearts.. but they have moved testified to being filled with the Holy Spirit, in many cases the Holy Spirit through prophesy and other such
supernatural means.. so yes God said they were Christian and not me..
however the bible says that you will know a tree by its fruit.. and these men produced good fruit.. and i'm not tying it to works.
savlation is by grace, we recieved that grace, and we fufill our purpose on earth, doing the good works, through the enabling of the Holy Spirit and not by the strength of our human flesh and not by our own rightouesness.. We do these works not to earn our way into heaven, but because We knows christs love and grace for us, and we know His calling of us to do these things for Him.. We are working out His plan in our lives, and he works through us... my showing Love (doing a work) to others can't save me.
actually if i am not already saved, i can't truely Love... my human love is pretty pathetic.. its only God's love overflowing and moving through me to others that can truely love others and Christ does and commands us to..

quote:

Ok the first thing and most broadest understanding is that that no man can say that Jesus is Lord without the help of the holy spirit.
So first level on intepretation .. would be that one would have to be saved, and thus have the Holy Spirit residing in one
to testify that Jesus is lord, and having said that, on the other hand you can't accurse Jesus if you do have the holy spirit..

By this claim if the Devil says the words 'Jesus is Lord' he will be saved. If I pay someone here $50 to say the words 'Jesus is Lord', they will be saved. I guarentee you that we both have the ability to control our mouths to the point of saying 'I curse Jesus'. I would not say it, but I also would not expect that saying it would immediately bankrupt my salvation.


thats the opposite of what i am saying... i am saying that people can say bare words "jesus is lord" but to actually proclaim them, it can only come from
the Holy Spirit in us.. and the devil doesn't have the holy spirit..

quote:

The positive thing says 'by the Holy spirit', the negative thing says 'speaking by the spirit of God'... if you interpret speaking by
the Spirit of God to exculsively mean by tounges.(which i disagree with). that would say that no man could curse God in tounges... which is probably true.

Haven't you had the JW's ask you how you know you don't curse Jesus in tongues if you can't understand what you say ? I don't mean that one only speaks 'by the Spirit' in tongues, but that is obviously the context of the three chapters coming, so my interperation is both in context, and means something real that needs to be pointed out.
[QUOTE]

they haven't, but if they did i'd probably answer the same as you... I believe the gift of tounges is from God and is via the Holy Spirit and the Holy Spirit
wouldn't curse God. i agree with that..
however i have encountered counterfiet tounges... in dealing with ministry of people coming from satanic covens, i've seen satanists have their eyes glow
red and speak in unknown tounges that weren't of the Holy Spirit..


[QUOTE]
however that doesn't say that saying that Jesus is the Lord is only capible of by tounges, it just says by the Holy Spirit..
The Holy spirit can lead us other than by tounges.. He helps us defend our faith in front of courts etc, in a real language too.
that is By the Holy Spirit.. and also speaking...

I agree totally, but that is not the context of these verses.



i believe it is the context of those verses. that whole chapter is about the various ways the Holy Spirit manifests itself in a believer..
and the foundation is our salvation and our proclaimation of our salvation is not possible without being filled with the Holy Spirit
but that has nothing to do with tounges.


quote:

which says that to ONe person is given a certian gift, and to another yet a different gift... and the body made of christians
execersings their different gifts and ministries work togeather for the purpose of Christ..
so not all christians may speak in tounges... and God doesn't require it.. its something that is good... very good..
and i believe that if you ask God for this gift , he'll ussually give it to you...
but not all christians speak in tounges..

I've already pointed out that above the verse you quoted it says there are many gifts but on manifestation that is given to all. In Acts 8 they had faith and healing, so how could they not have the Spirit if your reading of 1 Cor 12 means they had the manifestation of the Spirit ?


i am a lingust of many years in various languages (can't tell my my english spelling on here , hehe), and i can tell you that when it is talking to another its meaning different gifts to different people. its not exclusively saying that that only one gift per person.. but its not saying that every person has every gift either.

quote:

I do not speak in toungs becase I am not lead to.

That's because you're not being lead. The Bible offers you this gift, and all the others. Do you also claim not to be lead to pray to be healed ? Do you claim not to be lead to have faith ? If you want to throw out one of the gifts, you need to be prepared to throw them all out.

i didn't say that i do not speak in tounges because i am not lead to..

God Bless Karl
I am off for the weekend now.. most likely anyhow..

------------------
Karl Prosser
Karl / GODCENTRIC
Klumsy / Surprise ! Productions.
ME / Redeemed by the Living God :)
Klumsy@xtra.co.nz
May God Bless you, he sure does me.

MeanManInOz
Member

Posts: 388
From: Hobart, Tasmania, Australia
Registered: 06-26-2001
quote:

so anybody who doesn't speak in tounges isn't a true christian nor a brother in your understanding?
but i am (just) because even though i speak in tounges, i don't go so far as to say that if that all born again believers filled
with the Holy Spirit , speak in tounges?


You are walking disorderly, but the fact you speak in tongues means you have the Holy Spirit and are therefore a Christian.

I'd prefer not to talk in specifics though, it only makes people defensive.

quote:

SIT? huh? how could have he not known..

Speaking In Tongues. How could he have known how often they used a gift that was entirely in their control when he was not there ?


quote:

I belive we can Pray in the Spirit, and means in tounges... but tounges isn't the only way we interact with God or the only way the Holy Spirit interacts with us..

That is correct. So if prayer in the Spirit means tongues, and we're told to pray in the Spirit, what's that mean for those who can not ?


quote:

but there is no clear scripture that says "all christians (aka those who are saved) speak in tounges", that is a cultist heresy..

That's because you're looking for an order instead of an offer. There's plenty of scripture that is clear, and plenty more that makes no sense if this is not the case.


quote:

so were the apostles saved before or at pentecost? ...

Was salvation possible before the Holy Spirit was poured out ?

quote:

i didn't say that i do not speak in tounges because i am not lead to..

No, the guy who replied beneath you did - so I put his name and then replied to him as well.

You'll notice I'm only skimming your posts now. I'm waiting for you to explain Acts 8 to me in light of your theories. The rest is just going in circles now.

Klumsy

Administrator

Posts: 1061
From: Port Angeles, WA, USA
Registered: 10-25-2001

quote:

Speaking In Tongues. How could he have known how often they used a gift that was entirely in their control when he was not there ?
[QUOTE]
by dicernment of the holy spirit...

[QUOTE]
I belive we can Pray in the Spirit, and means in tounges... but tounges isn't the only way we interact with God or the only way the Holy Spirit interacts with us..

That is correct. So if prayer in the Spirit means tongues, and we're told to pray in the Spirit, what's that mean for those who can not ?



that is a point you have.. i will take it up with God and read and pray, and bare my heart before God, ask him to search my for all iniquity and lead
me in all truth.. i believe praying in the Spirit surpasses just tounges... there are very much intricacies in the langauges dealing in IN, by, OF, by the power of etc..
but however pray in the Spirit, and speaking by the inspiration of the Spirit aren't one in one..

quote:

but there is no clear scripture that says "all christians (aka those who are saved) speak in tounges", that is a cultist heresy..

That's because you're looking for an order instead of an offer. There's plenty of scripture that is clear, and plenty more that makes no sense if this is not the case.



i'm not looking for either an order or an offer, just clear scriptures..


quote:

so were the apostles saved before or at pentecost? ...

Was salvation possible before the Holy Spirit was poured out ?


Jesus said in the cross "it is finished, it is accomplished"... i believe peter was saved.. When he went out and wept after denying jesus, and poured out his
heart to God and prayed to God, i don't think he was not saved yet. because the Holy Spirit had been poured out... Sure he wasn't filled to the brim with the Holy Spirit
and thus no enabled to do the work God had for him, but he was indeed saved...

Anybody can read whatever they want out of the scriptures (me and you)..
I know i could speak in tounges, but i could say that the bible teaches reincarnation.. (i don't believe this of course)
however i coulkd take the scriptures where jesus says that Elijah had already come, and if you would believe it, that he was John..
(implying that of course the jews wouldn't believe in reincarnation) but actually John was the reincarnation of Elijah or something...
this is a load of Hogwash.. but one can twist the scriptures however (you and me included)..

I belivevce that from those overall scriptures and their context and dicernment of the Holy Spirit that not all christians have tounges
or much speak in it to be a christian..
sure maybe some people refuse it when God wishes them to happen.. If we disobey where God leads us (to even nutral things like giving up tennis if
God things its become an idol) then that is sin..

anyhow we are both convinced in our own minds to our stances whether that is out of self rightouesness, human pride, or Godly convictions, so
there is no point to argue at all..

How even if you aren't willing, I am willing to sacrifice my human understanding of it and God to my daddy, my father and ask him to lead me in greater understand.
I hope you are willing to do the same..

as far as act 8 goes i will study it in my bible while at parachute music festival and pray over it and get back to you next week,even though you don't give me
the courtesy of reading the whole words i write to you but just skim them.


love,
your wayward brother in Christ
Karl..

------------------
Karl Prosser
Karl / GODCENTRIC
Klumsy / Surprise ! Productions.
ME / Redeemed by the Living God :)
Klumsy@xtra.co.nz
May God Bless you, he sure does me.

Klumsy

Administrator

Posts: 1061
From: Port Angeles, WA, USA
Registered: 10-25-2001
woops i got the quotes messed up in the top section. i am sureyou can get around it..

sorry

karl

------------------
Karl Prosser
Karl / GODCENTRIC
Klumsy / Surprise ! Productions.
ME / Redeemed by the Living God :)
Klumsy@xtra.co.nz
May God Bless you, he sure does me.

MeanManInOz
Member

Posts: 388
From: Hobart, Tasmania, Australia
Registered: 06-26-2001
quote:

as far as act 8 goes i will study it in my bible while at parachute music festival and pray over it and get back to you next week,even though you don't give me the courtesy of reading the whole words i write to you but just skim them.

That's a bit harsh. The fact is I am at work, answering you while my code compiles, and I feel we've focused on the subset of my comments you feel you have an answer for. As we're only rehashing those comments over and over I feel I am not being unkind in not reanswering the same things when the other comments I have made have gone unanswered.

Klumsy

Administrator

Posts: 1061
From: Port Angeles, WA, USA
Registered: 10-25-2001
ok sorry for being harsh
i just thought if you had the time to answer my things you could at least read it, or wait until your priorities are taken care of

would you forgive me..

Karl

------------------
Karl Prosser
Karl / GODCENTRIC
Klumsy / Surprise ! Productions.
ME / Redeemed by the Living God :)
Klumsy@xtra.co.nz
May God Bless you, he sure does me.

MeanManInOz
Member

Posts: 388
From: Hobart, Tasmania, Australia
Registered: 06-26-2001
quote:
would you forgive me..

But of course, 70 times 7... ;0)

Angel

Member

Posts: 699
From: The Blissful State Of Me?
Registered: 05-21-2001
HAHA I stick my tounge at you! I do have faith hope and love thank you very much. I also do not have to speak in tounges to show that I love God so booo hoo for your theory cuz I dont care hahaha! I love God and he loves me and I hope and have faith that my love for him will get stronger. Besides what me and Him do together is non of your bizz. He understands me eather way I speak and I think He is alot happyer that I spend alot of time speaking to him insted of speaking in tounges only when I go to church to show to every one how holy I am. So that is how I look at it.

Love you too

------------------
Peaza Cheez Mates!
Azariah "Angel"

rowanseymour

Member

Posts: 284
From: Belfast, Northern Ireland
Registered: 02-10-2001
God Bless you Angel ! That's the spirit ! (...not the Holy Spirit - just a figure of speech :P)

------------------
Rowan / GODCENTRIC Christian Demoscene

MeanManInOz
Member

Posts: 388
From: Hobart, Tasmania, Australia
Registered: 06-26-2001
quote:

HAHA I stick my tounge at you!

Yes, but do you say Ni ???

quote:

I do have faith hope and love thank you very much.

You have your emotions, and belief in your religion. So do Hindus and Muslims. How do you propse that your Christianity is different from these religions, or Apex for that matter ?

quote:

I also do not have to speak in tounges to show that I love God so booo hoo for your theory cuz I dont care hahaha!

I thought you said I had not hit a nerve ? Instead of feeling threatened, why don't you do what the Bible says ? I note this post is full of bluster and short on answers to my comments from scripture. My desire is not to make you fdeel insecure, it's for you to be saved.

quote:

I love God and he loves me and I hope and have faith that my love for him will get stronger. Besides what me and Him do together is non of your bizz.

He does love you, but if you loved HIm, you'd do what He said. That's what Jesus said, anyhow.

quote:

He understands me eather way I speak and I think He is alot happyer that I spend alot of time speaking to him insted of speaking in tounges only when I go to church to show to every one how holy I am. So that is how I look at it.

Well, the problem is not Him understanding you, but you knowing what to pray for. That's what Romans 8 says, anyhow. You're right, 1 Cor 12-14 was written about people thinking they were holy and had to make a show of using the gifts in public. The point of 1 Cor 12-14 is indeed not to act this way, but in love for one another. Part of showing this love is to use the gifts in order, not looking to exalt yourself, and to understand that it's not any glory to you anyhow, because it's the work of God, and because every Christian is equally able to use the gifts.

Another part of showing God you love Him is to preach the Gospel, regardless of how personally people take it.....

rowanseymour

Member

Posts: 284
From: Belfast, Northern Ireland
Registered: 02-10-2001
Luke 23

39 One of the criminals who hung there hurled insults at him: "Aren't you the Christ? Save yourself and us!"
40 But the other criminal rebuked him. "Don't you fear God," he said, "since you are under the same sentence?
41 We are punished justly, for we are getting what our deeds deserve. But this man has done nothing wrong."
42 Then he said, "Jesus, remember me when you come into your kingdom. "
43 Jesus answered him, "I tell you the truth, today you will be with me in paradise."

This man was saved and yet did not speak in tongues.

------------------
Rowan / GODCENTRIC Christian Demoscene

MeanManInOz
Member

Posts: 388
From: Hobart, Tasmania, Australia
Registered: 06-26-2001
rowan you cannot use this verse to prove the rest of the Bible wrong. IF this man was saved it was by special dispensation direct from the mouth of Christ, before salvation was possible, as Christ had not yet died, let alone risen from the dead or sent the Holy Spirit. If Jesus appears to you in person and gives you a free ticket to avoid the necessity of accepting the wonderful gifts He has for you, then the NT does not apply to you either. :-)
rowanseymour

Member

Posts: 284
From: Belfast, Northern Ireland
Registered: 02-10-2001
It doesn't prove the rest of the Bible wrong - it only proves your interpretation of the bible wrong - and because I believe the bible is absolute and does not contradict itself - I am forced to conclude that you are wrong.

------------------
Rowan / GODCENTRIC Christian Demoscene

MeanManInOz
Member

Posts: 388
From: Hobart, Tasmania, Australia
Registered: 06-26-2001
OK, rowan, you are entitled to your own conclusions and to build them from one Bible verse. If you find more comfort in proving your salvation to yourself than evaluating what I have said from the Bible, I don't find that so hard to understand.

If you're willing to actually discuss it, I'd like to know on what basis you think Jesus words here can negate the fact that the Apostles, who had walked and talked with Jesus and done miracles, could refer to the events of Acts 2 as 'the beginning' ? ( Refer Acts 11 ) Or why Jesus had to die and rise again if salvation was freely available prior to that ? Or where it was that Jesus went that day ?

Briant

Member

Posts: 742
From: Stony Plain, Alberta, Canada
Registered: 01-20-2001
I guess people that cannot speak for whatever reason (mute, deformity, tongue cut out, MS, etc.) cannot be saved, eh?

Steven Hawking, the famous physicist, talks by means of a computer due to MS. If he believed in Christ, would his computer start speaking in other languages? LOL.

Sorry to poke a little fun, but I personally find this doctrine both ridiculous, unbiblical (yes unbiblical!) and dangerous. I suspect I'll catch some flak from Mr. Mean for saying that, but I'm not interested in getting deeply involved in this debate - I've found that these tongues=salvation folk are more stubborn than JWs, and certainly more elitist. They, like all fringe groups, have trouble distinguishing "the Bible" with "their interpretation of the Bible".

See ya in heaven, MeanMan, even though I don't speak in tongues!

I say:
"Jesus is the Lord! Jesus is the Christ!" - see 1 Cor 12:3 and 1 John 5:1, if you dare!

Brian

------------------

rowanseymour

Member

Posts: 284
From: Belfast, Northern Ireland
Registered: 02-10-2001
I could give you so many verses that proclaim salvation is found through belief in God and obeying his laws. You can only give me...

Acts 11
15 "As I began to speak, the Holy Spirit came on them as he had come on us at the beginning."

Couldn't this be the beginning of the Church ?

Doesn't it seem strange to you that Jesus only mentions tongues once ? If it is essential to salvation you would think he might have wanted to be clear about it.

Hear what Jesus does say!

Matthew 12
49 Pointing to his disciples, he said, "Here are my mother and my brothers.
50 For whoever does the will of my Father in heaven is my brother and sister and mother."

Mathhew 21
28 "What do you think? There was a man who had two sons. He went to the first and said, `Son, go and work today in the vineyard.'
29 "`I will not,' he answered, but later he changed his mind and went.
30 "Then the father went to the other son and said the same thing. He answered, `I will, sir,' but he did not go.
31 "Which of the two did what his father wanted?" "The first," they answered. Jesus said to them, "I tell you the truth, the tax collectors and the prostitutes are entering the kingdom of God ahead of you.

Matthew 7
21 "Not everyone who says to me, `Lord, Lord,' will enter the kingdom of heaven, but only he who does the will of my Father who is in heaven.
22 Many will say to me on that day, `Lord, Lord, did we not prophesy in your name, and in your name drive out demons and perform many miracles?'
23 Then I will tell them plainly, `I never knew you. Away from me, you evildoers!'

John 14
23 Jesus replied, "If anyone loves me, he will obey my teaching. My Father will love him, and we will come to him and make our home with him.

------------------
Rowan / GODCENTRIC Christian Demoscene

[This message has been edited by rowanseymour (edited January 24, 2002).]

MeanManInOz
Member

Posts: 388
From: Hobart, Tasmania, Australia
Registered: 06-26-2001
quote:

I guess people that cannot speak for whatever reason (mute, deformity, tongue cut out, MS, etc.) cannot be saved, eh?

The basic premise of any hypothetical like this is that God does not have power to deal with the situation being discussed. We have formerly mute people in our church. My neighbours are deaf and dumb, and I will still preach to them. God has ordained the sign of the Spirit, the details are up to Him and He is well able.

quote:

Sorry to poke a little fun, but I personally find this doctrine both ridiculous, unbiblical (yes unbiblical!) and dangerous. I suspect I'll catch some flak from Mr. Mean for saying that, but I'm not interested in getting deeply involved in this debate - I've found that these tongues=salvation folk are more stubborn than JWs, and certainly more elitist.

You're entitled to your opinion, and ultimately our opinions are irrelevant, only God's opinion matters. If you're not willing to discuss why you think this doctrine is unBiblical, you cannot expect your comments to have any credibility, but it seems you've had bad experiences in the past ? I'm pleased there are people in the US preaching the Gospel, but I am sorry if, from the sounds of it, they go about it the wrong way. It is however my experience that telling people who believe in Jesus they can be saved is hard, because they find the 'you're not quite there yet' bit elitest and confronting, as if my trying to tell them the Gospel is being done for my own glory or as if I rejoice in the fact that many call Him Lord and yet will not enter in.

quote:

I say:
"Jesus is the Lord! Jesus is the Christ!" - see 1 Cor 12:3 and 1 John 5:1, if you dare!

I've spoken at length on 1 Cor 12-14 already, you should read some of the other threads. 1 Cor 12 states that there are many gifts but a common manifestation of the Spirit given to all. 12-14 is written to people all speaking in tongues at once in meetings, which is wrong. 1 Cor 12 points out there are many gifts and for the body to function when it comes together different people must do different things, 13 points out that the gifts are a tool for this age, and love is eternal, the gifts are subservient to love. 14 points out the nuts and bolts, we can all speak in tongues, interpret and prophect, but there is an order in which God would have us use these gifts in the church.

The verse you pointed out is stating that when someone speaks 'by the Spirit' ( which in context with 1 Cor 14 is speaking in tongues ), they cannot curse Jesus, and that unless one can praise Him in this way, they cannot call Him Lord. I hope you're not suggesting that it's saying anyone who says the words 'Jesus is Lord' is saved ? To say that anyone who curses Jesus in an understood language is not speaking by the Spirit is obvious, has nothing to do with the context of the verses around it, and is just plain pointless.

5:1 Everyone who believes that Jesus is the Christ is fathered by God, and everyone who loves the father loves the child fathered by him.

Absolutely - and the Bible also says what to believe about Jesus, which includes His death, resurrection, and ascention to the Father, to send the Holy Spirit. It also includes the promise that believers will speak in tongues. It CERTAINLY means someone who does what Jesus told him to.

This verse is written to the saved, it is not a precise description of who Jesus is, what to believe about Him, or how to show that we believe ( faith without works is dead, we show our faith by acting on it ).


Briant

Member

Posts: 742
From: Stony Plain, Alberta, Canada
Registered: 01-20-2001
quote:

If you're not willing to discuss why you think this doctrine is unBiblical, you cannot expect your comments to have any credibility,

I did not post for credibility.

quote:

but it seems you've had bad experiences in the past ? I'm pleased there are people in the US preaching the Gospel,

Well, they're preaching something but I wouldn't call it the Gospel. Some fringe groups preach you need to speak in tongues. Others preach that you absolutely must not. Others preach you must be water baptised to be saved, others preach you must read only a 1611 KJV to be saved, others preach you must handle snakes to be saved, others preach you must learn Hebrew to be saved, others preach you can only sing psalms to be saved, others preach you can only say the name "Jesus" when baptizing to be saved, others preach that "Jesus" is invalid and you must only use "Yeshua" to be saved, others preach that you don't have to preach at all because the predestined have no choice but to be saved regardless. All are wasting everyone's time. I just wish these fringe groups would wake up and simply preach Christ cruicified and stop focusing on their pet doctrines and running around in circles hitting each other and everyone else with their Bibles. If you tongues=salvation people would simple preach Christ to people, instead of arguing with people about tongues, you might actually do some good.

quote:

as if my trying to tell them the Gospel

Good example of my previous comment about your confusion about the Gospel and your interpretation of the Gospel.

quote:

I've spoken at length on 1 Cor 12-14 already,

Yes, a great many people have said a great many things. And the more fringe a doctrine, the more explanation it needs.

I'm done, I'm already feeling grimy from getting even this far into this useless discussion. No hard feelings, but I've been down this road many times before and I know where it leads.

------------------

MeanManInOz
Member

Posts: 388
From: Hobart, Tasmania, Australia
Registered: 06-26-2001
Bryant, you're free to do as you wish, but if you don't want to discuss it, why start ?

How does one preach Jesus if one ignores the Bible ? The arguing only starts when preaching to the semi-converted. The Bible both requires baptism and offers tongues as the sign of the Spirit. The scriptures verify this, and my own experience proves it to me. That's in decending order of importance.